5 Great Lou Gehrig Baseball Cards (Guide to the Iron Horse)

Lou Gehrig baseball cards are desired by collectors for more than their monetary value. Not even his amazing baseball statistics explain the enormous demand for his cards and memorabilia.

Although a Lou Gehrig rookie card is among the most valuable baseball card in the world, his cards pay tribute to a man of honor and one of the game’s most extraordinary gentlemen.

Lou Gehrig, Instant Legend

When Lou Gehrig was 17 years old, his High School team from New York traveled to Chicago to play Lane Tech High School at what is now Wrigley Field. Gehrig didn’t disappoint.

Ten thousand people filled the major league stadium to watch two high school teams play. Little did the crowd know they were watching one of the greatest baseball players who ever lived.

With Gehrig’s team-leading 8-6 in the ninth inning, Lou hit a grand slam home run out of the stadium, and the legend was born. Lou would become one of the all-time greats ever to play the game.

Lou Gehrig, The Iron Horse

Nicknamed “The Iron Horse” for his durability and toughness, Lou Gehrig had a fantastic 17-year professional baseball career.

Lou was an all-star seven years in a row, won the triple crown and league MVP twice, and hit 493 home runs.

Not only that, but he had a career batting average of .340 and was a six-time world series champion as a member of the New York Yankees.

Hall of Fame Career, All-Century Team Player

He played in 2,130 consecutive games and hit 23 grand slams. Both were records for nearly 50 years.

With all his hits on the field, fans knew him as a mild-mannered and soft-spoken intellectual, and often attended operas and Broadway shows with his wife.

lou gehrig career stats
Lou Gehrig’s Career Highlights

Every year the Lou Gehrig Memorial Award is given to the major leaguer who best exemplifies Gehrig’s character and integrity both on and off the field. 

Of his many baseball records, one of the most stunning is Gehrig scored more than 100 runs and at least 100 Runs Batted In for 13 consecutive seasons, while his career was only 14 seasons long.

Incredible video footage of Lou Gehrig, one of the greatest ballplayers of all time.

Lou Gehrig Baseball Cards

If you’re interested in collecting sports cards or just a baseball fan in general, there are 5 great Lou Gehrig baseball cards to know about.

If you’ve been lucky enough to own some of these great cards, then you are well aware of the rapid price increases in recent years.

Only 10 or 20 years ago, some of these cards were available in decent conditions for meager prices compared to what they are going for today.

Lou Gehrig Rookie Card Value

Here’s the value of Lou Gehrig’s rookie cards from their most recent auction sales. Of the five most recognized Lou Gehrig rookie cards, the 1933 Goudey card tops the list with a sale of $576,000 in 2019 at Heritage Auctions.

The record-setting Gehrig card is graded at a PSA 9 condition, with only one other card of similar condition. No other 1933 Goudey Gehrig rookie cards are graded higher than the PSA 9 sale.

lou gehrig most valuable cards
Lou Gehrig Rookie Card Value – and the 12 most expensive sales of Lou Gehrig cards.

1933 Goudey Lou Gehrig – $576,000

The 1933 Goudey is one of my all-time favorite Lou Gehrig baseball cards.

I love the simplistic layout showing nothing but the left-handed slugger getting ready to unleash his swing.

The entire 1933 Goudey set is known for its colorful and distinct design, making the cards easily recognizable. In this 1933 Goudey set, Lou Gehrig is featured twice.

1933 Lou Gehrig baseball card
The 1933 Goudey Lou Gehrig card

1933 Goudey Lou Gehrig PSA 10 $275,000 Memory Lane Auction of 2007

There are cards #160 and card #92, which are rarely found in high-grade mint or near-mint condition.

If a 1933 Goudey Gehrig #160 with a PSA rating of 9 or a mint condition card were to come up for auction today, it would be sure to bring in hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Limited Supply of the 1933 Goudey Gehrig Rookie Card

Professional Sports Authenticator, otherwise known as PSA, reports only five 1933 Goudey Lou Gehrig cards graded at a MINT 9 rating.

There’s only one single card with a PSA GEM MT 10 rating. If this card were to sell at auction today, it would surely be among one of the most valuable baseball cards ever.

The Goudey Gum Company

The Goudey Gum Company was founded in 1919 by Enos Goudey. Opening the first factory in Boston, Enos was an up-and-coming businessman who decided to enter the baseball card world in 1933 when he debuted Goudey Baseball.

Goudey began by producing a 239 card set in 1933, which marked the beginning of sports cards packaged with bubble gum in every pack.

The 1933 Goudey trading cards were the first important bubble gum cards and helped create an entire generation of collectors.

1932 U.S. Caramel Lou Gehrig – $45,000

1932 US Caramel lou gehrig baseball cards
The 1932 U.S. Caramel Lou Gehrig

Many would consider the 1932 U.S. Caramel card the closest thing to a Lou Gehrig rookie card.

Although there were a few cards in the 1920s like the Exhibits card shown below featuring Gehrig, this was the first mainstream card.

Back in the day, when these cards were issued, they could be redeemed for baseball equipment. This is definitely one of my favorites of the 5 great Lou Gehrig baseball cards.

1925 Exhibits Lou Gehrig Baseball Card – $250,000

1925 Exhibits Lou Gehrig rookie card
1925 Exhibits Lou Gehrig card

The 1925 Exhibits card is one of the earliest Gehrig cards produced. It’s extremely rare, and cards in the best condition can be incredibly valuable.

From the first full year Gehrig played for the Yankees, the first card of Gehrig might be the most prominent of all Exhibits cards produced.

Some hard-core card collectors call the 1925 Exhibits the official Lou Gehrig rookie card.

Exhibit Supply Company

The Exhibit Supply Company from Chicago began producing baseball cards in 1921.

They were distributed from vending machines making the Exhibit cards the first cards that weren’t meant for the advertisement of an add-on product such as gum, caramel, or tobacco.

The earliest cards could be purchased for one penny and were usually found in arcades.

Whatever your opinion is on the true rookie card of Lou Gehrig, there’s no denying the Exhibits Gehrig is a legendary trading card.

1933 DeLong Lou Gehrig – $75,000

1933 DeLong Lou Gehrig
The 1933 DeLong Lou Gehrig card

Harold DeLong started the DeLong Gum Company in 1932 after working as an engineer, chemist, and treasurer for the Goudey Gum Company until 1928.

Harold developed confectionery and chewing gum machinery that would later be acquired by Gum Products Inc. In 1933, DeLong decided to try their hand at baseball cards to compete with Goudey.

The hard-to-find Delong Lou Gehrig card from 1933 includes population reports of only eight known cards graded by PSA at an 8 rating.

1934 Goudey Lou Gehrig Baseball Cards – $200,000

1934 Goudey lou gehrig
The 1934 Goudey Lou Gehrig card

In 1934, Goudey featured a classic Lou Gehrig card where the slugger hit .363 and won the triple crown.

The back of the card features a quote from Gehrig that says, “I love the game of baseball and hope to be in there batting them out for many years to come, fortune has been kind to me.”

There were two Gehrig cards from the 1934 Goudey set, a #37 and a #61 card, showing the slugger in a batting pose. Card #37 is reported to have only three PSA 9 graded cards with zero PSA 10 cards.

The Goudey Gehrig Card

The value for a PSA 9 card is roughly $200,000. For comparison, the 1933 Goudey Babe Ruth cards have only one PSA 9 rating in existence – so far. This card is valued at nearly $900,000.

It’s amazing what happens when supply goes from three to only one. You can try to compare Babe Ruth to Lou Gehrig all day long, but in my opinion, there could be incredible value in purchasing low-grade PSA Lou Gehrig cards for the long term.

Other Great Lou Gehrig Cards

Upper Deck featured Lou Gehrig on a card in 2008 called the Upper Deck Premier Legendary Remnants series.

The card is a limited edition series, including a sample of an authentic game-used jersey. This card can be found for $300 – $400, depending on the grade.

1927 Lou Gehrig Strip Card W560 – $12,600

Not many card collecting experts would argue the Gehrig Strip Card to be one of the great baseball rookie cards, but it’s certainly original.

PSA reports only one card with a Gem Mint 10 rating. The 3 of Clubs Lou Gehrig is a rare card indeed.

1927 Lou Gehrig Strip Card W560
1927 Lou Gehrig Strip Card W560

1962 Topps Lou Gehrig and Babe Ruth Baseball Card #140

The epic 1962 Topps, “Babe Ruth Special,” card number 140, features Babe Ruth with his arms around a smiling Lou Gehrig.

1962 Topps Lou Gehrig and Babe Ruth Baseball Card #140
1962 Topps Lou Gehrig and Babe Ruth

1972 Lou Gehrig Kellogg’s All-Time Baseball Greats

Collectors Universe reports only 66 PSA 10 cards, with an estimated value of $360.

1972 Lou Gehrig Kellogg's All-Time Baseball Greats
1972 Lou Gehrig Kellogg’s All-Time Baseball Greats

1960 Lou Gehrig Fleer Baseball Greats

1960 Lou Gehrig Fleer Baseball Greats
1960 Lou Gehrig Fleer Baseball Greats

1933 Goudey Lou Gehrig Rookie Card #92 BVG 1.5

Here’s an idea if you just have to get your hands on a Gehrig rookie.

Here’s the 1933 Goudey card in BVG 1.5 condition selling on eBay for $2,560.

That’s a great card, and for just a couple grand, you could have your very own Gehrig rookie. (with round corners)

lou gehrig goudey rookie
The Goudey rookie, selling on eBay for $2,560.

The Sudden Demise of The Iron Horse

Halfway through the 1938 season, Gehrig reported physical challenges. After the season, he was quoted saying, “I was tired mid-season. I don’t know why, but I just couldn’t get going again.”

By spring training the following year in early 1939, Gehrig was having difficulty running the bases and had lost the explosive power at the plate.

Gehrig would struggle early in the regular season before taking himself out of the lineup, where his consecutive games played streak would end at 2,130.

The Iron Horse and The Iron Man

Baseball’s greatest record would stand for nearly fifty years before Cal Ripken passed the mark.

A few months later, after a trip to the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota, he was diagnosed with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis ( ALS ) on June 19, 1939. Gehrig would turn 36 years old that same day.

Gehrig Retires

Less than a month later, on July 4th, 1939, Gehrig would deliver his retirement speech at Yankee Stadium, where he would famously say he was “the luckiest man on the face of the earth.”

He was a legendary ballplayer who shattered many records, which some still stand to this day. If you’re lucky enough to own a few of these 5 great Lou Gehrig baseball cards or just a fan of collecting, you can understand how they are such an important piece of baseball history.

He ended his epic retirement speech by saying, “…I might have been given a bad break, but I’ve got an awful lot to live for. Thank you.”

His retirement speech is one of the most remembered moments in American sports and baseball history.

In a Class All His Own

There were so many incredible ball players over the years. Roberto Clemente, Ty Cobb, Joe Dimaggio, Ted Williams, Mickey Mantle, Honus Wagner.

But I’m not sure there was anyone like Lou Gehrig.

The amount of success Gehrig had on the ball field was second to none.

His rapid decline from a brutal disease made his career even more amazing. His much-to-early, untimely, and some would say tragic death spread sadness throughout the game of baseball and left a void that nobody could fill.

Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, otherwise known as Lou Gehrig’s disease, still has no cure. Its cause is unknown, but researchers continue to study treatment and possible prevention.

Lou Gehrig delivers his famous speech at Yankee Stadium.

A Few More of My Favorite Lou Gehrig Cards

Of course I can afford my own Lou Gehrig rookie card, but I do own a few of his cards.

They might be the least-valuable Gehrig cards out there, but it’s still pretty cool to have a few.

By now, there’s dozens of re-print Gehrig cards in commemoration of the man. And some of those re-prints are extremely valuable.

lou gehrig baseball card
1992 The Sporting News Triple Crown Winner #529
iron horse baseball player
Hygrade Baseball’s All-Time Greats

Card Collectors –> Looking to Sell Baseball Cards? Here’s How (and Where) To Do It

Looking for the nearest sports card shop? Here’s how to find them!

Leave a Comment

Contact Us